#rt-boot-overlay { display: none !important; }

Rate Tony: Kill Tony Ratings, Transcripts, and Rankings

Q: How do I vote for Guest of the Year?

Click the Vote button on a guest card. One vote per device keeps the leaderboard fair.

Q: When does voting end?

Voting closes December 31, 2026. Results are announced at the start of 2027.

Q: Can I change my vote?

Yes. If you already voted for a guest, click Remove to retract it, then vote for a new favorite.

Q: How are rankings calculated?

Rankings are driven by live vote counts. Ties factor in guest appearances and recency of episodes.

Q: Where can I see a guest's appearances?

Open the guest profile from their card to see linked episodes, highlights, and performance history.

Rate Tony is a fan-run platform focused on Kill Tony episodes. The site tracks episode-level ratings, minute-by-minute highlights, transcript context, guest and host trends, and member appearance history.

JavaScript is currently disabled in your browser, so interactive features are unavailable. You can still browse key pages directly:

Episodes and recaps with community scoring context
Member profiles with appearances and related episode links
Minute indexes and trends for historical comparisons

KILLTONY

Community Rankings

Kill Tony Guest of the Year 2026

Community-run Kill Tony Guest of the Year 2026 rankings with 46 nominees, 244 verified votes logged, and direct links to appearances.

Nominees: 46
Total votes: 244
Updated: Jun 9, 2026

Ranking Methodology

What this leaderboard measures

Guest of the Year rankings are based on RateTony community votes for guests connected to 2026 Kill Tony episodes. Vote totals drive the visible ranking; appearances and recency are available as sorting context. This is a RateTony community leaderboard, not an official Kill Tony award result.

Ratings methodology Guest profiles Rating trends Best episodes

Episode appearances

Recent nominee episode links

Open the guest profile or the episode page to verify the RateTony source data behind each nominee.

Brad WilliamsinKT #771
Jun 8, 2026
Sheryl UnderwoodinKT #770
Jun 1, 2026
Tom SegurainKT #770
Jun 1, 2026
Mat EdgarinKT #769
May 25, 2026
Chris O'ConnorinKT #769
May 25, 2026
Shane GillisinKT #768
May 18, 2026
James MccanninKT #768
May 18, 2026
Peyton RuddyinKT #767
May 11, 2026

Guest of the Year Rules

Eligible guests: any comedian featured as a guest on a Kill Tony episode during 2026.

Cast your vote by clicking the 'Vote' button on the guest's card.

Voting period: January 1 - December 31, ends at 11:59 PM.

Winner: guest with the highest vote count is crowned 'Guest of the Year.'

Limit one vote per device for 2026; repeat votes are not counted.

Ultimately, Tony chooses and none of this matters but it is fun :)

Leaderboard Controls

Sort & Vote GOTY contenders

46 nominees displayed.

Total Votes Cast

244

Sort By: Votes

Kill Tony Guest of the Year 2026

What this leaderboard measures

Recent nominee episode links

Guest of the Year Rules

Sort & Vote GOTY contenders

Peyton Ruddy

Shane Gillis

James Mccann

Rick Ingraham

Theo Von

Sam Tallent

Adam Ray

Dr Phil

Tim Butterly

Sal Vulcano

Bert Kreischer

Sheryl Underwood

Rob Schnieder

Roseanne Barr

Adam Ray

Jeremy

Joe DeRosa

Brad Williams

Tom Segura

Mat Edgar

Chris O'Connor

Luis J Gomes

Ari Shaffir

Dustin Poirier

The Undertaker

Jeff Ross

Jelly Roll

H. Foley

Kevin Ryan

Steve-O

Joe List

Stephen Rannazzisi

Donnel Rawlings

Trevor Wallace

Matt Rife

Ian Fidance

Jim Norton

Greg Fitzsimmons

Jim Breuer

Tommy Pope

Steve Byrne

Gabriel Iglesias

Harland Williams

Carrot Top

Joe Rogan

Tony Hinchclone

Guest of the Year FAQ